While this might be attributable to several factors, a major consideration is that the work samples were not designed a priori to reflect the rubrics of the ability outcome. The last 2 criteria on the problem-solving VALUE rubric, implement solution and evaluate outcomes, were often scored as NA, and were the most common reason for an incomplete score. Third, there was a realization that continued improvements in the assessment process would require providing faculty members with additional forums to discuss and act on the assessment data and to share personal experiences regarding how the assessment data were used to improve course assignments. While a low yield for problem-solving samples precluded meaningful data analysis, the assessment process was informative for indicating areas for potential curricular improvement. Typically, the third assessment provided for agreement on the assessment of the work sample. At the conclusion of each assessment day, the faculty assessors engaged in a guided debriefing discussion of their reflections on the validity, reliability, and feasibility of the process and the value of the assessment findings. In January , faculty members teaching required courses were asked to review the modified VALUE rubrics to determine if any student assignments or practice opportunities in their courses addressed either or both critical thinking or problem solving.

The primary investigator was largely responsible for planning the assessment days and collecting student work samples. Received Mar 1; Accepted Apr Accreditation Council for Pharmacy Education. For this reason, while the rubric can be used if the assignments or purposes for work are unknown, it will work most effectively when those are known. This planning work required approximately hours. Please login to view pages 2 – 1.

AACU Problem Solving : Outcomes & Rubrics

Using the VALUE rubrics, faculty assessors evaluated each work sample by assigning a score for each criterion included in the rubric. Integrative wacu is an understanding and a disposition that a student builds across the curriculum and co-curriculum, from making simple connections among ideas pproblem experiences to synthesizing and transferring learning to new, complex situations within and beyond the campus.


Louis College of Pharmacy, St. Recognizing this unique opportunity, the need for programmatic assessment, and the validity of VALUE rubrics for assessing program-level ability outcomes, faculty members at St.

Individuals with strong QL skills possess the ability to reason and solve quantitative problems from a wide array of authentic contexts and everyday life situations. Beyond mere exposure to culturally different others, the campus community requires the capacity to: Using a high-quality rubric makes assessment, grading, and evaluation both easier and more precise.

Rubric scoring allowed assessors to evaluate four 5- to 7-page work samples per hour. Persuasive evidence regarding how well college students are actually doing in terms of critical thinking, problem solving, and other liberal education outcomes is lacking. The primary investigator was largely responsible for planning the assessment days and collecting student work samples. It means promoting the quality of life in a community, through both political and non-political processes.

Problem-solving was identified as a curricular area that may need improving. Helping students more overtly examine and express their thinking processes can also be tied to gains in the development of self-regulated learning, in which students are capable of self-assessing what they know, what is still confusing to them, and the gains they have made over the course of their studies.

Ratings of the critical-thinking ability outcome also became less variable and more consistent in latter years of the curriculum.

aacu problem solving rubric

For panel presentations or group presentations, it is recommended that each speaker be evaluated separately. Prepared by the University of Hawai’i, Manoa. All statistical tests were conducted at an alpha level of 0.

aacu problem solving rubric

However, having gained a notion of performance levels in the current curriculum, we will ensure that future teaching and learning activities will concentrate on honing these abilities and future assessments on demonstrating progressive development toward mastery.

Reflection allows analysis and interpretation of the work samples prroblem collections of work for the reader. National Center for Biotechnology InformationU.

VALUE Rubrics

You can also modify them to serve your program’s unique needs. They provide very valid and reliable means for assessing sixteen key student learning outcomes.


This paper describes the inaugural effort with respect to establishing a baseline assessment, elaborating assessment methodologies, and establishing methods for data management and analysis, with experiences illustrated using the critical-thinking and problem-solving ability outcomes.

The key in the development of such work samples or collections of work will be in designing structures that include artifacts and reflective writing or feedback that support students’ examination of their learning. The results of the assessment of critical thinking, in contrast, provided evidence that the outcome was practiced in each academic year of our curriculum, and performance levels increased as students progressed from matriculation to graduation. After assessment, faculty members discussed the following as part of a guided debriefing: This rubric is specifically designed to evaluate oral presentations of a single speaker at a time and is best applied to live or video-recorded presentations.

This assessment method has great potential to inform continuous quality improvement of a PharmD program. Therefore, the analysis reported here contains only student work sample records that provided complete assessment information for all criteria in the VALUE rubric.

Following the calibration process, each de-identified student work sample was then evaluated independently by at least 2 faculty assessors. It can involve working with many different writing technologies, and mixing texts, data, and images. Allen at Miami-Dade College. Finally, faculty are encouraged to adapt the essence and language of each rubric criterion to the disciplinary or interdisciplinary context to which it is applied.

aacu problem solving rubric

Please login to view pages 2 – probkem. Oral communication is a prepared, purposeful presentation designed to increase knowledge, to foster understanding, or to promote change in the listeners’ attitudes, values, beliefs, or behaviors.